Great Film: In the Cut
Obviously Cuts Too Deep for Some
Deary me, some people get upset when a film isn't what they want it to be,
don't they? How dare the film be what the film-makers set out to make,
instead of what someone's narrow expectations dictate it should b?
Fancy In the Cut being gritty, seamy, sexy and deeply disturbing ... just
like all the publicity (and the rating) warned us it would be. What a
shock. How did the people expecting another Piano, or Meg Ryan Finds True
Love Yet Again ever find themselves in the cinema?
As for those who have said they have walked out completely unmoved ...
either they must be aliens or robots, or are fooling themselves, not wanting
to acknowledge the truth of what they've seen on the screen. Seldom have I
seen a film that so truly examines the dark side of our sexual impulses. I
walked out quite shattered, and wandered around in a daze for a
while.
Meg Ryan completely miscast? Ridiculous and insulting. How dare you tell an
actress she has to be Little Mary Sunshine for the rest of her life. And she
pulls it off brilliantly. She and Mark Ruffalo give the most stunning lead
performances for a long time. Why? Because they're playing real,
multi-layered people. Not goody-goodies or baddy-baddies.
Didn't like any of the characters? Must have a very limited range of
acquaintances, or alternatively, don't like the real people you do
know.
Thriller plot not thrilling? Admittedly it's not the strongest point in the
film, but it has all the required shocks and surprises (and, you'd think
enough gore for the modern audience), and while the revelation of the
murderer is not the biggest twist ending ever, the final shot takes your
breath away.
And anyway, Campion, while handling the thriller genre competently, is using
it as a means to explore sexuality. And attraction. And how much of love
involves physicality, carnality, trust, the desire to dominate, the desire
to be dominated, and above all, the attraction of the DANGEROUS. Yes, adult
stuff, not often tackled in mainstream films.
I think it's her best film ever (possibly excepting Sweetie), and I give it
9 out of 10.
Cast
- Detective Malloy played by Mark Ruffalo
- Frannie played by Meg Ryan
- Pauline played by Jennifer Jason Leigh
- Frannie's Young Father played by Micheal Nuccio
- Young Father's Fiancee (as Alison Nega) played by Allison Nega
- Attentive Husband played by Dominick Aries
- Perfect Wife played by Susan Gardner
